The nominated energy efficiency projects and the prize winners were selected by an expert jury made up of representatives from politics, business, science and the media. The jury members will receive all submitted applications for screening. They are obliged to comply with the statutory provisions on data protection and to maintain confidentiality. In a joint meeting, the jury decides in a technical debate. The experts evaluate all submitted energy efficiency projects according to uniform standards based on the criteria of energy saving, climate protection relevance, economic efficiency, degree of innovation and transferability.
The technical evaluation of the submitted and accepted applications is based on uniform criteria. For the categories "Energy turnaround 2.0", "Energy efficiency: from clever to digital" and "Energy services and energy management", these are the criteria:
- Relative energy savings: The reduction in energy requirements achieved by increasing energy efficiency (before/after).
- CO2 savings: Reduction in CO2 (absolute). The energy savings achieved are evaluated using uniform emission factors for energy sources (according to GEMIS1).
- Economic efficiency: Ratio of the cost savings achieved by the energy efficiency measures implemented to the investments made.
- Innovation: Major innovations in terms of technology, production methods, process management, organisation - also in combination. In addition, impulses for further innovations are taken into account.
- Transferability: Market potential for the realisation of similar projects in other companies (in the sector or across the board).
The assessment of submitted concepts for increasing energy efficiency is carried out analogously to the criteria mentioned by means of a potential assessment. The jury also assesses the plausibility and marketability of the concept.
A shortlist of nominated projects will be published in October 2019. All nominated companies will be reported to the national and international trade and business press as part of the official media work of the Energy Efficiency Award even before the award ceremony. The published projects are entitled to actively use the nomination for their own corporate communications.
The award ceremony
The winners of the Energy Efficiency Award will be honoured with publicity on 26 November 2020. All winners of the categories "Think Big! Complex Energy Efficiency Projects", "From clever to digital! The range of energy efficiency" and "Achieving more together! Energy services as enablers of energy system transformation" will receive a certificate from dena and prize money of 8,000 euros per category. The three companies nominated for the audience award will present their concepts for increasing energy efficiency at the awards ceremony or online. The audience will then decide in an interactive voting process which concept will receive this award. The winner will receive a certificate and prize money of 6,000 euros.